Did Angus Robertson Address the Heritage Agency Crisis Effectively?
Angus Robertson faced criticism for allegedly "being asleep at the wheel" amid the difficulties engulfing Historic Environment Scotland (HES), the Scottish Government's heritage agency. Questions arose about whether he could have done more to prevent the crisis or if he was actively managing the situation.
Scrutiny at Holyrood Committee
As Scotland's Culture Secretary, Robertson was challenged at a Holyrood committee hearing where the ongoing turmoil within HES was discussed. Scottish Conservative MSP Stephen Kerr led the critique against Robertson, supported by party colleague Jamie Halcro Johnstone. Robertson defended his role with backing from SNP deputy leader and committee member Keith Brown.
Concerns Over Leadership at HES
Recent press reports have highlighted problems within HES, particularly concerning its senior management. Chief Executive Katerina Brown, appointed in September of the previous year, had been on leave since June but recently returned to sign off the agency’s accounts. However, she has yet to resume full responsibilities as chief executive.
Agency Role and Funding
The Scottish Government provides £74 million annually to HES to care for and promote over 300 of Scotland's key historic and environmental heritage sites. These include landmarks such as Edinburgh Castle and the neolithic Skara Brae settlement on Orkney.
"Was he proactive in dealing with its troubles? Were his hands on the wheel or was he asleep at it? This was the issue confronting the culture secretary."
The committee also learned that while Katerina Brown has returned to finalize reports, full leadership duties remain unfulfilled, deepening concerns over the agency’s management stability.
Author’s summary: Angus Robertson faced tough questions over his handling of Historic Environment Scotland’s crisis, balancing scrutiny against ongoing leadership challenges within the agency.